Hot Roof vs. Cold Roof: Which One Is Better?

The phrases “heat roof” and “chilly roof” are sometimes used on the subject of roofs, however what do they actually imply? What is the distinction between them? And which is the higher selection to your dwelling?

A sizzling roof is unventilated and makes the attic livable, however makes the house extra susceptible to ice dams. Chilly roofs are the normal roof building; They’re ventilated and guarantee higher temperature regulation between the roof and the dwelling house. Generally, chilly roofs are higher for cooler climates and heat roofs are perfect for pitched roofs.

Do you want roof, facade or gutter installers?

Obtain free, no-obligation quotes from skilled contractors close to you.


What’s a sizzling roof?

A sizzling roof is a kind of roof construction that isn’t ventilated. The insulation is put in beneath the roofing, leaving no house for air flow. With out air flow, the room is hotter, which is the place the time period “sizzling roof” comes from.

Sizzling roofs are mostly seen on new builds and buildings with pitched roofs.

Advantages of sizzling roofs

Beneath are the principle benefits of a heat roof.

Usable attic

Relying on the construction of the home, the nice and cozy roof building makes the attic usable and livable. As a result of it brings the attic into the thermal shell of the home. The attic then maintains the identical degree of moisture and air regulation as the remainder of the house.

Trapped conditioned air

With an unventilated sizzling roof, conditioned air can not escape from the home. This implies owners do not must “warmth (or cool) outdoors” and might get monetary savings on heating and air con payments.

vitality effectivity

The nice and cozy roof insulation ensures the insulation of your complete roof construction. A heat roof is extra vitality environment friendly than a chilly roof.

simple set up

So long as the present roof terrace is in good situation, it’s simple to put in a heated roof on it.

value effectiveness

The insulation of a heat roof affords extra thermal insulation than a chilly roof. With further thermal safety comes higher economic system.

Disadvantages of sizzling roofs

Whereas sizzling roofs have many benefits, there are additionally some disadvantages to think about.

Essential to seal the attic

Within the case of sizzling roofs with out air flow, higher consideration have to be paid to making sure that the attic is sufficiently hermetic.

Excessive set up prices

Though sizzling roofs are cheap, they’ve comparatively excessive set up prices. Sizzling roofs sometimes use spray foam insulation, which is costlier than bulk or batting insulation. In addition they require the set up of an air barrier and vapor barrier to guard the attic from altering climate.

Chance of moisture, mildew and ice jam

The principle function of a heat roof is that it has no air flow. Nonetheless, this implies there’s a increased probability of moisture build-up, which might result in mildew progress. This additionally implies that sizzling roofs are extra vulnerable to ice build-up than chilly roofs.

Ice jam happens when an ice ridge kinds on the fringe of the roof. This ridge prevents melting ice from draining off the roof. Because of this, water and ice gather, push beneath the clapboards and seep into the house.

This may end up in vital weight masses on the roof which can be too nice for the construction. Ice dams may trigger injury to insulation, ceilings, partitions, and different areas of the house.

Elevated constructing top and better roof profile

One other drawback of a sizzling roof is that the general top of the constructing is elevated because of the increased profile of the roof.

Diminished ceiling top

Because of the insulation required for a heat roof, the ceiling top of the attic is diminished. Doorways and home windows will also be obstructed by the insulation. They might not open correctly because of the means a sizzling roof is put in.

What’s a chilly roof?

A chilly roof, often known as a ventilated roof, has been the normal roof construction for many years. The attic just isn’t a part of the air-conditioned house of the home with chilly roofs. As an alternative, the insulation separates the air between the conditioned house and the attic.

Chilly roofs will need to have a vent baffle, ridge or gable vent, and soffit vents. The insulation is laid between the rafters. Air can stream unhindered beneath the roof membrane.

The meeting of chilly roofs is taken into account simple and delicate.

Benefits of chilly roofs

Listed here are a number of the key advantages of a chilly roof.

cooler in summer season

Chilly roofs hold properties cooler in the summertime, leading to decrease cooling prices.

No ice dams

Because the roof stays cool in winter, a correctly put in chilly roof prevents ice build-up. Ice dams may cause main injury to your private home, so stopping them is extraordinarily necessary.

Higher temperature regulation

In heat climates, the air flow of a chilly roof regulates the temperature distinction between the home and the roof. For instance, when the solar beats down on the roof, this warmth can’t be simply transferred to the dwelling house of the home.

Simple set up through the building part

If a chilly roof is put in throughout building, the insulation may be utilized shortly and simply.

No change to the constructing profile

The insulation used for a chilly roof is inefficient and doesn’t have an effect on the peak or profile of the constructing.

Disadvantages of chilly roofs

Similar to sizzling roofs, chilly roofs even have some disadvantages to concentrate on.

Troublesome to put in after building

One of many benefits of chilly roofs is their ease of set up through the building course of. Nonetheless, one of many disadvantages is that insulating an present flat roof is time-consuming and tough. To do that, the present roof space have to be torn open and changed. This not solely takes effort and time, however will also be costly.

Much less thermal effectivity

In comparison with heat roofs, chilly roofs are thermally much less environment friendly.

Essential to seal attic

Much like sizzling roofs, chilly roofs have to be sealed hermetic. On this means, the conditioned air doesn’t combine with the skin air. If the attic just isn’t correctly sealed, the HVAC system must work more durable. This will improve heating and cooling prices and require the system to get replaced earlier.

Sizzling roof vs. chilly roof: analysis standards

Right here we evaluate heat and chilly roofs immediately utilizing plenty of totally different analysis standards.

local weather

Generally, sizzling roofs aren’t very appropriate for cooler climates. It is because sizzling roofs are extra prone to ice dams, which might trigger main injury to properties. In chilly climates, a chilly roof is often the higher selection.

That is to not say that sizzling roofs robotically result in ice build-up, mildew, and moisture issues. A correctly hermetic attic mustn’t have these issues. The issue is that these issues are usually much less noticeable on a construction with a sizzling roof.

In hotter climates, each sizzling roofs and chilly roofs can work properly. Nonetheless, chilly roofs in sizzling climates often supply the very best financial savings on the subject of cooling prices.

home-owner wants

If a home-owner desires their attic to be usable or perhaps a dwelling house, then a sizzling roof is greatest. With a heat roof, the attic is usually the identical temperature as the remainder of the home. It’s going to have the identical air regulation and humidity as the opposite dwelling areas.


Relying on the blueprints for a house or different construction, one sort of roof could also be higher than the opposite. Generally, heat roofs are simpler to put in. They add top to flat roofs and are extra preferrred for pitched roofs, however additionally they have wonderful thermal efficiency.

Constructions with roof balconies, flat roof extensions or doorways main onto the roof aren’t appropriate for decent roofs. For properties like this, a chilly roof is the one choice.

Chilly roofs are simple to put in if finished on the first stage of building. However when owners wish to ventilate their roof after building, it is undoubtedly a problem. Putting in a chilly roof after building entails eradicating the present roof, including insulation, after which changing it.

associated questions

What’s the distinction between a heat and a chilly roof?

The principle distinction between a heat roof and a chilly roof is the situation of the insulation. The insulation of a heat roof is on the floor of the present roof. With a chilly roof, then again, the insulation is between the rafters.

How sizzling do roofs get?

It is determined by the skin temperature and the kind of roofing materials. In some instances, the roof temperature may be as excessive as 170 levels Fahrenheit.

Why does a chilly roof must be ventilated?

A chilly roof have to be ventilated in order that the warmth can escape beneath the shingles.

Do you want roof, facade or gutter installers?

Obtain free, no-obligation quotes from skilled contractors close to you.


Sizzling Roof vs. Chilly Roof: The Last Verdict

General, each sizzling roofs and chilly roofs have their execs and cons. Every is best suited to particular climates and conditions.

Sizzling roofs are vitality environment friendly, simple to put in and comprise conditioned air. They flip attics into livable areas. Nonetheless, they arrive with excessive set up prices and an elevated probability of ice jam and water injury.

Chilly roofs are higher at regulating temperature and are much less vulnerable to ice dams. They alter neither the peak nor the profile of the constructing. Nonetheless, they’re tough to put in as soon as constructed and are much less thermally environment friendly.

Jessica Allen

With a lifelong ardour for writing and a powerful enthusiasm for DIY and residential enchancment tasks, becoming a member of the group at Upgraded Residence was a straightforward selection. Jessica Allen is completely happy to share useful info with present and potential owners. Apart from writing, Jessica likes to do yoga, play the piano and dabble in graphic design.